Skip to content

What Happens If You Do Nothing During Medicare Open Enrollment?

If you do nothing by December 7, your Medicare plan usually renews for 2027. When that's fine, when to review it, and what to do if your plan is ending.

The short answer: If your Medicare Advantage or drug plan will still be offered in 2027 and you do nothing by December 7, you stay in it. Your coverage continues automatically on January 1, with the plan’s new 2027 premium, copays, drug list and network. If you have Original Medicare with a Medigap policy, nothing changes either, because open enrollment doesn’t apply to Medigap. The exception is a plan that won’t be offered next year: then you get a separate letter, and different rules and deadlines apply.

One of the most common questions this time of year is: do I have to sign something every year to keep my plan? No, you don’t. But “nothing changes” isn’t quite true either. The plan stays, but its terms for 2027 can be different. Medicare’s own guide puts it carefully: if you’ve reviewed your options and you’re happy with your current coverage, you don’t need to do anything. The key word is “reviewed”.

Does my Medicare plan renew automatically?

Yes. If you’re in a Medicare Advantage plan or a stand-alone Part D drug plan and it continues in 2027, you don’t need to re-enroll. Your coverage continues, and any changes in benefits and costs take effect on January 1. Those changes are described in the Annual Notice of Change (ANOC), which your plan had to send by September 30.

Two more things renew on their own. A Medigap policy can’t be canceled by the insurance company as long as you pay the premium (all Medigap policies issued since 1992 are guaranteed renewable), although the premium itself can change. And if you use the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan, which spreads drug costs into monthly payments, your participation renews for 2027 as long as you stay in the same Part D plan.

When is doing nothing a reasonable choice?

Staying in your plan is a perfectly good decision when you’ve checked the ANOC and can answer yes to these points:

  • your doctors and hospital are still in the plan’s network in 2027,
  • all your medications are still on the drug list, at the same tier and without new restrictions,
  • your pharmacy is still in network, preferably as a preferred pharmacy,
  • the premium, deductibles and yearly out-of-pocket limit haven’t gone up in a way that matters to you,
  • your own situation hasn’t changed: no new diagnosis or expensive new medication, no move, no long stays away from home.

According to CMS, about 8 in 10 Medicare Advantage members can stay in their current plan in 2027 with the same or a lower premium. That’s good news, but the premium is only one line in the letter.

When has my plan changed enough to take a closer look?

What you see in the ANOCWhy it mattersWhat to do
A drug moved to a higher tier or off the listYour copay for that drug can go up noticeablyCompare plans with your full drug list
A doctor or hospital leaves the networkIn an HMO those visits may not be coveredCall the office; compare plans that include them
Higher deductible or out-of-pocket limitA year with a hospital stay costs moreCompare the total yearly cost, not the premium
An extra benefit you use is reduced or droppedYou may pay for it yourselfCheck whether it matters enough to switch
Your plan is combined with another planYou’ll be moved automatically, but the terms may differRead the ANOC as if it were a new plan

Example (a typical situation, not a specific person): someone has a Medicare Advantage plan with drug coverage and uses a brand-name inhaler. In the 2027 ANOC the premium stays the same, so it looks like a reason to do nothing. But the inhaler moves to a higher tier, and the yearly cost of that one drug goes up. That’s exactly the case where 30 minutes of comparing makes sense. I describe how to check this in the article on five questions to ask before changing plans.

My plan is leaving Medicare. Is that the same thing?

Older woman at a kitchen counter reading a letter with a concerned but calm expression

No. A plan that renews with changes is one situation. A plan that won’t be offered at all next year (a non-renewal), or stops serving your county, is a different one. The plan has to tell you by mail at least 90 days before coverage ends, so usually in early October. In that case your coverage under the plan ends after December 31, and you have these options:

  • Choose a new plan by December 7. It starts on January 1, with no gap.
  • Use the special right to choose until the last day of February. If your plan’s contract isn’t renewed, you have a Special Enrollment Period from December 8 to the end of February 2027. A plan chosen after January 1 starts later than January 1.
  • If you do nothing, you’ll be in Original Medicare from January 1. That means Part A and Part B, but no drug coverage unless you join a stand-alone drug plan. Going 63 days or more without drug coverage can lead to a late enrollment penalty later.
  • Medigap without health questions. If your Advantage plan leaves Medicare or stops serving your area and you switch to Original Medicare, federal law gives you a guaranteed issue right to buy certain Medigap policies (Plan A, B, D or G, or C and F if you were eligible for Medicare before 2020) sold in your state, without health questions. You can apply up to 60 days before your Advantage coverage ends, and no later than 63 days after it ends.

If you have a stand-alone drug plan that’s ending, the same Special Enrollment Period applies. If you do nothing, you’ll have no drug coverage from January 1, so it’s worth choosing a new plan before then.

Note! A letter saying your plan won’t be offered in 2027 is not something to put aside. It’s the one situation in which doing nothing can leave you without drug coverage. Bring the letter to the office or call me, and we’ll go through your options and deadlines.

What if I miss December 7?

If your plan renewed and you realize in January that it doesn’t fit, people in a Medicare Advantage plan can make one change between January 1 and March 31: switch to another Advantage plan or go back to Original Medicare with a drug plan. Certain life events, such as moving or losing other coverage, open Special Enrollment Periods. Otherwise, the next chance is next fall.

How I can help

At a free consultation, in person at 3410 N. Harlem Ave. or 6500 W. Archer Ave., or by phone, we read your ANOC together and check your doctors, medications and pharmacy against your plan for 2027. If everything still fits, you’ll hear that from me and you can leave the plan as it is. The first meeting takes about 30 minutes. Bring your Medicare card, the ANOC or any letter from your plan, and your list of medications. (773) 620-5258.

Olivier Wasilewski
Independent insurance broker, founder of Medicare On The Spot. Nearly 20 years in Medicare, including UnitedHealthcare's Medicare division as manager of independent agents and director of ethnic markets for Illinois. Licensed in: IL, FL, AZ, WI, CO, IN, TX, MI, CT, NV, TN, WA, NC, SC, MO, OK, UT.
Last updated: November 2026

This article was prepared with the help of AI tools, then reviewed and approved by Olivier Wasilewski, licensed insurance broker.

Common questions about doing nothing during open enrollment

Do I have to re-enroll in my Medicare Advantage plan every year?

No. If your plan is offered in 2027, your coverage continues automatically. Reviewing it is optional, but worth the time.

Will my Medigap policy renew automatically?

Yes. All Medigap policies issued since 1992 are guaranteed renewable: the company can’t cancel your policy as long as you pay the premium. The premium itself can change.

If my plan leaves Medicare and I do nothing, will I lose Medicare?

No. You’ll have Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) from January 1. To have drug coverage, you need to join a stand-alone drug plan, by December 7 or during the Special Enrollment Period that lasts until the end of February.

My plan is being combined with another plan from the same company. Do I need to do anything?

Usually you’re moved to the new plan automatically. Read its ANOC as carefully as if you were choosing a new plan; until December 7 you can still pick a different one.

Sources

  1. Medicare.gov: Your Yearly Medicare Review, September 2026
  2. Medicare.gov: Medicare & You 2027 (official handbook; "What are my rights if my plan stops participating in Medicare?")
  3. Medicare.gov: Special circumstances (Special Enrollment Periods)
  4. Medicare.gov: Choosing a Medigap Policy, March 2026 (guaranteed issue rights)
  5. CMS press release, Sept. 28, 2026: Medicare Advantage and Medicare Prescription Drug Programs Expected to Remain Stable in 2027
  6. eCFR: 42 CFR 422.506, Nonrenewal of contract (notice to enrollees)
  7. eCFR: 42 CFR 422.530, Plan crosswalks
  8. Medicare.gov: Open Enrollment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *