Skip to content

Do You Pay More for Medicare If You Use an Agent? How Independent Agents Are Paid

Your Medicare premium is the same with or without an agent. Who pays independent agents, how much CMS allows for 2027, and what you get from one.

The short answer: No. Your premium is the same whether you enroll on your own, on Medicare.gov or through a licensed agent, because Medicare rules require a plan to charge the same premium to everyone enrolled in it. Agents also aren’t allowed to charge you a fee to process your enrollment. Independent agents are paid by the insurance company whose plan you choose, within limits CMS sets every year. For 2027, the national maximum for a new Medicare Advantage enrollment is $725.

When you’re comparing Medicare plans, it’s natural to wonder what working with an agent will cost you. Below I explain how the money actually flows, which rules CMS (the federal agency that runs Medicare) sets for it, and what an independent agent gives you that a website or a TV ad doesn’t.

Will my premium be higher if I enroll through an agent?

No. Federal rules say a Medicare Advantage plan’s premium and copays may not vary among the people enrolled in that plan (42 CFR 422.262). Stand-alone Part D drug plans must also have a uniform premium and benefits across their service area (42 CFR 423.104). In other words, there’s no “agent price” and no “online price”. Your neighbor who enrolled on Medicare.gov and you, who enrolled at an agent’s desk, pay exactly the same for the same plan.

Medicare’s marketing rules also say plainly that plans and agents can’t charge you a fee to process your enrollment into a plan. If anyone asks you to pay for help joining a Medicare Advantage or drug plan, that’s not how it’s supposed to work, and you can report it to 1-800-MEDICARE.

So who pays the agent?

The insurance company whose plan you choose. When an independent agent helps you join a Medicare Advantage or Part D plan, the insurer pays the agent a commission. It’s part of the insurer’s own cost of running the plan, it isn’t billed to you and it doesn’t change your premium.

CMS limits how much an insurer may pay an independent agent. The limits are recalculated every year and published in a memo to the plans. For coverage starting January 1, 2027, they are:

Type of plan (2027)First yearEach following year
Medicare Advantage, with or without drug coverage (national amount, which applies in Illinois)up to $725up to $363
Stand-alone Part D drug planup to $130up to $65

A few details in these rules work in your favor:

  • No bonus for switching you every year. If you move from one Medicare Advantage plan to another, the new plan generally pays only the lower renewal amount, not a new first-year commission.
  • A quick change costs the agent. If you leave a plan within the first three months, the insurer takes back the whole commission (with exceptions, for example when you move or qualify for Extra Help).
  • One plan, one payment. In a Medicare Advantage plan with drug coverage (MAPD), the agent is paid only the Medicare Advantage amount, not a second commission for the drug part.
  • Training every year. An agent must be licensed in your state and pass each insurer’s yearly Medicare test with a score of 85% or higher.

These are maximums. Insurers can pay less, and some have paid agents nothing for certain plans. CMS mentioned concerns about this in its June 2026 memo and asked plans to report it voluntarily. So it’s fair to ask any agent: are there plans in my area you don’t work with?

What’s the difference between an independent agent and a captive agent?

A captive agent works with one insurance company and can only offer that company’s plans. They may know those plans very well, but they can’t tell you whether another company’s plan fits your doctors better. An employed agent is on the insurer’s payroll. An independent agent (often called a broker) has contracts with several insurance companies and can put their plans side by side.

QuestionCaptive or employed agentIndependent agent
Whose plans can they offer?One company’sSeveral companies’
Who pays them?The insurer (salary or commission)The insurer (commission within CMS limits)
Is your premium different?NoNo
Can they compare companies?NoYes, among the companies they work with

Federal rules also require an agency that sells plans from more than one company to tell you how many organizations and plans it represents in your area and, if it doesn’t offer every plan, to say so. You’ll hear that short disclaimer at the start of a sales call and see it on the agency’s website.

What do I get from working with an independent agent?

Senior man talking on the phone at his kitchen table with a cup of coffee

A website can show you a list of plans. A good agent goes through them with your life in mind. In practice, that means:

  • Several companies in one conversation, compared against your actual doctors, hospital, pharmacy and prescriptions. Medicare rules require agents to go through these topics before you enroll.
  • Help with the application, so the enrollment form is filled out correctly and nothing gets held up.
  • Someone to call during the year, when a bill doesn’t make sense, the pharmacy won’t fill a prescription or a letter arrives from your plan.
  • A review every fall, when your plan sends its Annual Notice of Change and you decide whether to stay or switch.
  • A local office you can walk into, and a person who already knows your situation.
  • Polish, if you prefer it, for yourself or for a parent you’re helping.

What isn’t an agent allowed to do?

Medicare’s marketing rules are there to protect you. A plan or agent can’t:

  • call you unless you’ve given permission or you’re already a member of their plan,
  • come to your home uninvited,
  • charge you a fee to process your enrollment,
  • offer you cash, or gifts worth more than $15, to join a plan,
  • pressure you, or have you sign the enrollment form before you’re ready,
  • steer you to a plan or call it “the best”.

Before a meeting, the agent will also ask you to confirm which types of plans you’d like to talk about. That short form is called a Scope of Appointment, and it’s a CMS requirement, not paperwork for its own sake.

Note! If you think you joined a plan because someone gave you wrong or misleading information, call 1-800-MEDICARE and explain your situation. That applies no matter who you enrolled with.

How I can help

At a free consultation, in person at 3410 N. Harlem Ave. or 6500 W. Archer Ave., or by phone, I compare plans from several insurance companies using your doctors and your prescriptions, and I help you with the application if you decide to enroll. The first meeting takes about 30 minutes. There’s no fee for the consultation, and your premium is the same as if you enrolled on your own. (773) 620-5258.

Olivier Wasilewski
Independent insurance broker, founder of Medicare On The Spot. Nearly 20 years in Medicare, including UnitedHealthcare's Medicare division as manager of independent agents and director of ethnic markets for Illinois. Licensed in: IL, FL, AZ, WI, CO, IN, TX, MI, CT, NV, TN, WA, NC, SC, MO, OK, UT.
Last updated: November 2026

This article was prepared with the help of AI tools, then reviewed and approved by Olivier Wasilewski, licensed insurance broker.

Common questions about Medicare agents and cost

Do I have to enroll if I meet with an agent?

No. You can take the information home, think it over, or enroll on your own at Medicare.gov. Medicare rules don’t allow an agent to pressure you or have you sign before you’re ready.

Does an agent earn more if I choose a plan with a higher premium?

Not in the way most people imagine. CMS sets one maximum amount per enrollment, not a percentage of your premium. Insurers can pay less than that maximum, and the amounts can differ between companies, which is why it’s reasonable to ask an agent how they’re paid.

What about Medigap? Do I pay the agent for that?

The CMS limits above apply to Medicare Advantage and Part D plans. Medigap (Medicare Supplement) policies are regulated by the states, and there too the agent is paid by the insurance company, not by you. If you’re unsure, ask your agent directly.

Is there free help that isn’t connected to an insurance company?

Yes. 1-800-MEDICARE is available 24 hours a day, and in Illinois the Senior Health Insurance Program (SHIP) offers free counseling at 1-800-252-8966. An independent agent adds something different: comparing plans with you, completing the application and staying with you after you enroll.

Sources

  1. Medicare.gov: Plan marketing rules (what plans and agents can and can't do)
  2. CMS: Contract Year 2027 Agent and Broker Compensation Rates, Referral/Finder's Fees, Submissions, and Training and Testing Requirements (memo to plans, June 1, 2026); CMS agent/broker compensation page
  3. eCFR: 42 CFR 422.2274, Agent, broker, and other third-party requirements (Medicare Advantage)
  4. eCFR: 42 CFR 423.2274, Agent, broker, and other third-party requirements (Part D)
  5. eCFR: 42 CFR 422.262(c), Uniformity of premiums (Medicare Advantage)
  6. eCFR: 42 CFR 423.104(b), Uniform premium and benefits (Part D)
  7. eCFR: 42 CFR 422.2267(e)(41), Third-party marketing organization disclaimer
  8. Illinois Department on Aging: Senior Health Insurance Program (SHIP)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *